Skip to Main Content
  • Fay's Diner & Cafe logo top
    Fay's Diner & Cafe logo scroll
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • Go to top
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Fay's Diner & Cafe logo topFay's Diner & Cafe logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs

Specials

Weekly Dinner SpecialsEarly Bird SpecialsWeekly SpecialsFay’s Dinner Menu

Shared Plate Charge $2.00

Starter

Steakhouse Wedge Salad

$15.00
Iceberg, gorgonzola, cherry tomatoes, bacon, chives with crispy onion
Strings and blue cheese dressing | Add shrimp, chicken, salmon, or steak (upcharge)

Entrees

Spaghetti and Meatballs

$21.00
Spaghetti, marinara, Italian meatballs, and Pecorino parmesan

Pork Saltimbocca

$35.00
Pan-seared pork tenderloin, crispy prosciutto, pork berry jus and sage. Served with sauteed vegetable medley and garlic mashed potatoes

Blackened Swordfish

$36.00
Grilled, blackened swordfish with Puttanesca sauce served with sauteed vegetables and rice pilaf

4 pm - 5 pm

Menu

Greek Salad with Chicken

$10.00
Add Salmon +$2.00

Ceasar Salad with Chicken

$10.00
Add Salmon +$2.00

Drugstore Smashburger

$10.00
No side included

Taco's

$5.00/each
No side included

Fish & Chips

$13.00

Blackened Salmon with Sauteed Vegetables

$13.00

Grilled Chicken with Sauteed Vegetables

$10.00

Half Sandwich & Daily Soup

$10.00

Menu

El Paso Benedict

$22.00
Poached eggs with avocado, chorizo, and chipotle Hollandaise on English muffin

Chocolate Banana Bread Pudding

$22.00
Banana brioche French toast with chocolate chips, bananas, vanilla cookies, and banana cream. Topped with whipped cream

Salmon Wrap

$21.00
Grilled or blackened salmon with spinach, arugula, cucumbers, red onions, and Puttanesca sauce

Cinnamon Rolls

All cinnamon rolls are made in house

Buy the Box

4 for $24.00 | 6 for $30.00

Plain

Finished with maple bourbon syrup

Frosted

Finished with our cream cheese frosting

Maple Bacon

Finished with maple bourbon candied bacon

Mudslide

Finished with chocolate syrup, caramel syrup, and crushed Oreos

Pecan

Finished with candied pecans

Almond

Finished with toasted almonds

Available Wednesday- Saturday 4pm-8pm

$2.00 split plate charge.

Starters

Small Salad

$5.00
Romaine lettuce, cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, red onion, croutons, with choice of dressing.

Ceasar Salad

$6.00
Romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese, croutons, caesar dressing.

Soup of The Day

Cup $6.00 | Bowl $9.00

Truffle Fries

$10.00
Bowl of crispy fries tossed in truffle oil, shaved parmesan, chopped herbs, and a garlic aioli dipping sauce.

Truffle Mac and Cheese

$15.00
Cavatappi pasta smothered in our house made white cheddar mornay sauce, bacon, truffle oil, shaved parmesan, herb breadcrumbs.

Crab Cake

$15.00
House made lump crab cake made crispy served with arugula, pickled shallots, pickled chili, frisee, cherry tomatoes tossed in balsamic vinaigrette. Served with tarter sauce.

Fries

Cup $5.00 | Bowl $8.00

Onion Rings

Cup $5.00 | Bowl $8.00 • Hand battered tempura onion rings.

Entrees

All Dinner entrees come with a half Biscuit and maple bourbon butter. Additional biscuit and butter is $3.00 each.

Chicken Piccata

$24.00
Pan-seared chicken breast in a piccata cream sauce, served with herb rice pilaf, and sauteed vegetable medley.

Shrimp Scampi

$26.00
Sauteed Shrimp, confit tomatoes, garlic, shallot, herbs, tossed in our scampi cream sauce, fettucine, and topped with parmesan cheese.

Steak Frites

$36.00
Grilled 8oz New York steak topped with our brandy peppercorn au poivre sauce, served with parmesan herb truffle fries, and a side for roasted garlic aioli.

Chicken Pot Pie

$23.00
Roasted chicken, onion, celery, carrots, garlic, potatoes, and herbs all cooked down in a creamy savory gravy, topped with puff pastry.

Cajun Salmon and Shrimp

$29.00
Blackened Salmon smothered in shrimp, peppers, onions, and a Cajun cream sauce, served with rice pilaf, and sautéed seasonal vegetables.

Beef Bourguignon Pasta

$26.00
Slow braised short rib, roasted cipollini onions, mushrooms, garlic, herbs, tossed in our bourguignon sauce, and cavatappi pasta, topped with parmesan cheese.

Chicken Parmesan

$26.00
Crispy breaded chicken breast, topped with marinara, mozzarella, pecorino romano, and parmesan cheese. Served with spaghetti tossed in marinara and finished with chopped basil.

Mushroom Risotto

$25.00
Arborio rice, seasonal mushroom medley, garlic, shallot, herbs, tossed in a roasted mushroom cream sauce, parmesan, and topped with a balsamic reduction..
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs